Criminal Defence | Bail Matters | High Court Litigation
+91 8109631969Call advakhlesh369@gmail.comEmail Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh Bhopal
Legal articles / Criminal Law
Criminal Law

Section 23 BSA: Can Police Use Your Confession as Evidence?

Can a confession made to police be used against an accused in court? Section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), explains why police confessions are generally inadmissible and when information leading to the discovery of a fact can become evidence in a criminal trial.

Lawyer Akhlesh Gautam 26 Oct 2026 8 min read 145 views

What Is Section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023?

Section 23 BSA governs the admissibility of confessions made to police officers and by persons in police custody.

A confession is a statement in which a person admits committing an offence or substantially admits the facts constituting it.

Under Indian criminal law, a confession made to police cannot ordinarily be used as evidence to establish the accused person's guilt.

This protection helps prevent the use of confessions obtained through pressure, threats, coercion or improper interrogation.

Section 23 BSA contains three important legal rules:

  • Section 23(1): Confessions made to police officers are inadmissible against an accused.

  • Section 23(2): Confessions made while in police custody are generally inadmissible unless made in the immediate presence of a Magistrate.

  • Proviso to Section 23(2): Limited information leading to the discovery of a fact may be proved in court.

These rules substantially correspond to Sections 25, 26 and 27 of the former Indian Evidence Act, 1872.

Section 23(1): Can Police Use an Accused's Confession in Court?

Section 23(1) provides that a confession made to a police officer cannot be proved against a person accused of an offence.

For example, suppose police question a person suspected of theft.

During interrogation, the person states:

"I stole the jewellery from the house."

Even if the statement was made voluntarily, the prosecution cannot ordinarily use that police confession itself to establish guilt.

However, the exclusion of a police confession does not mean the entire criminal case becomes invalid. The prosecution may still rely on other legally admissible evidence, such as CCTV footage, witness testimony or recovered property.

The court must distinguish between a confession and other forms of statements or admissions, which may be governed by different evidentiary rules.

Section 23(2): Are Confessions Made in Police Custody Admissible?

Section 23(2) provides an additional safeguard concerning confessions made while a person is in police custody.

Such confessions generally cannot be proved against the person unless made in the immediate presence of a Magistrate.

This restriction is important because police custody creates circumstances in which a person may be vulnerable to improper pressure.

For example, suppose an accused person is detained at a police station and makes a confession to another individual while remaining in police custody.

The confession does not automatically become admissible merely because it was not made directly to a police officer.

A confession made in the immediate presence of a Magistrate is not prohibited by Section 23(2) on that ground alone. However, it must still satisfy the applicable rules concerning voluntariness and admissibility.

Section 183 BNSS separately regulates the judicial recording of confessions and statements by Magistrates.

Discovery of Facts: When Can Information Given to Police Become Evidence?

The proviso to Section 23(2) creates a limited exception commonly called the discovery of facts rule.

If an accused person in police custody provides information that leads to the discovery of a fact, the portion of the information distinctly connected with that discovery may be proved in court.

This exception does not make the accused's entire confession admissible.

For Example:

Suppose a person accused of theft tells police:

"I stole the jewellery and hid it inside a cupboard in my rented house."

Police visit the location and recover the jewellery.

In this situation, the information identifying the concealed jewellery and its location may be admissible, subject to the legal requirements.

However, the words admitting the theft do not automatically become admissible merely because the jewellery was recovered.

The prosecution must separately establish the connection between the recovered jewellery and the alleged offence.

The important distinction is between information leading to a discovery and an admission of having committed the crime.

What Happens if Police Do Not Recover Anything After a Disclosure Statement?

A disclosure statement does not automatically become admissible merely because it was recorded during police interrogation.

For the discovery exception to apply, the prosecution must establish that a fact was discovered as a consequence of information received from an accused in police custody.

Suppose an accused tells police that a weapon is hidden at a particular location, but the police search the area and find nothing.

In such circumstances, the prosecution cannot rely on the discovery exception merely because the accused identified a possible location.

The statement's admissibility must be examined under the applicable provisions, and no discovery can be assumed.

Likewise, where a fact was already known to investigators, the court must examine whether the information genuinely resulted in discovery of a new relevant fact.

Important Judgment: Pulukuri Kottaya v. Emperor (AIR 1947 PC 67)

One of the leading decisions on the discovery of facts principle is Pulukuri Kottaya v. Emperor, reported in AIR 1947 PC 67.

The Privy Council examined the admissibility of information supplied by accused persons that resulted in the recovery of objects connected with an alleged offence.

What Was the Legal Issue?

The central question was whether the prosecution could prove an entire statement containing both information about a concealed object and an admission that the object was used to commit the crime.

What Did the Court Decide?

The Privy Council explained that the discovery exception permits proof only of the information distinctly relating to the discovered fact.

The discovered fact may include the location of an object and the accused's knowledge of that location.

However, an accompanying statement claiming that the object was used to commit the offence is not automatically admissible under the discovery exception.

Why Is This Judgment Important Today?

Although the judgment interpreted Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, its reasoning remains relevant to the corresponding discovery proviso under Section 23 BSA.

The decision helps courts distinguish between admissible discovery-related information and inadmissible portions of a confession.

Can a Co-Accused's Disclosure Statement Be Used Against Another Person?

Suppose Accused A tells police that Accused B was also involved in a criminal offence.

Can A's statement automatically establish B's guilt?

No. Merely naming another person during police interrogation does not establish that person's criminal liability.

If A's statement amounts to a police confession, the restrictions under Section 23 BSA must be considered.

If the information leads to the discovery of a fact, only the legally admissible portion may be proved, subject to the statutory conditions.

Section 24 BSA separately governs the limited consideration of certain legally proved confessions involving accused persons jointly tried for the same offence.

However, these evidentiary restrictions do not automatically prevent police from investigating B or making a lawful arrest where the applicable statutory requirements are satisfied.

Does Section 23 BSA Apply to Every Criminal Investigation?

The BSA came into force on 1 July 2024. However, the law applicable to a particular proceeding may depend on when it commenced and the transitional provisions governing pending proceedings.

For example, proceedings already pending before commencement may continue under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, where the applicable saving provision requires it.

Therefore, both the relevant dates and procedural history should be checked before determining which evidence law governs a case.

Legal References

[1] Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — Section 23. Restrictions on confessions made to police officers and in police custody, including the discovery of facts exception.

[2] Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — Section 24. Consideration of certain legally proved confessions involving jointly tried accused persons.

[3] Pulukuri Kottaya v. Emperor, AIR 1947 PC 67. Privy Council decision explaining the limited admissibility of information connected with the discovery of facts under the former Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act.

[4] Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — Section 183. Procedure governing the recording of confessions and statements by Magistrates.

[5] Indian Evidence Act, 1872 — Sections 25, 26 and 27. Former provisions substantially corresponding to Section 23 BSA.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Can police use a confession made during interrogation as evidence in court?

Q2. Is a confession made in police custody valid if no Magistrate is present?

Q3. Can a disclosure statement be used as evidence if police recover a weapon or stolen property?

Q4. What happens when police fail to recover anything after recording a disclosure statement?

Q5. Can a co-accused's police confession be used to prove another person's guilt?

Disclaimer

This article is published for general legal information and educational purposes only. It provides an overview of Section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, and the legal principles explained in Pulukuri Kottaya v. Emperor (AIR 1947 PC 67). It does not constitute legal advice or establish an advocate-client relationship.

The admissibility of police confessions, custodial statements and disclosure statements depends on the facts of each case, the circumstances in which the statement was made, the nature of any discovered evidence and the applicable statutory provisions. The legal principles discussed do not automatically invalidate an investigation or guarantee bail, discharge, acquittal or any other legal relief.

Readers should consult a qualified criminal-law advocate for advice specific to their circumstances. In the event of any inconsistency, the applicable law and authoritative judicial decisions shall prevail.

Reader comments

Write a comment

Your email remains private. Comments are reviewed before publication.

Interested in legal article updates?

Tell us which topics you would like updates about.

LEGAL INFORMATION NOTICE

Important Disclaimer

This website provides general information about Lawyer Akhlesh Gautam and his areas of legal practice. The content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, solicitation, advertisement or any guarantee of outcome. Viewing this website or submitting an enquiry does not by itself create an advocate-client relationship.